6 Comments
Apr 24Liked by Elise Labott

So insightful and poignant, an important much needed read by an excellent journalist.

Expand full comment
Apr 24Liked by Elise Labott

A poignant piece full of feelings during this terrible conflict that brought out the violent antisemitism not only at the US university, but all over the what we used to call the “civilised” world. My wife and I also saw Charlton Heston and Yul Brynner yesterday in our living room in Tel Aviv. And I was thinking how much easier it would be if we could just open a passage through the sea and have only all Hamas and Jihad terrorists drown there. But that is not possible. Watching the Ivy League students in their protests based on ignorance I wonder if these same students would protest against the allied bombing of Dresden and demand humanitarian aid to the suffering Germans?

Expand full comment
Apr 24Liked by Elise Labott

Less a celebration and more a reminder that the struggle never ends. Shalom

Expand full comment

To me as a faraway observer this is what stands out. The guilt of the innocent civilians losing lives while one defends their families and future, on the other hand the celebration post the massacre of innocent civilians. Maybe I have take a side subconsciously but what Hamas did and perhaps supported by Iran is what led to this tragedy. If Iran had the military that Israel had and if Israel was on the receiving end I fear what would have transpired. I dare say we would have seen no protests by Arab world or the university students for that matter.

Expand full comment
Apr 25Liked by Elise Labott

Very resonant piece Elise. Thank you.

Here is a poem I wrote before going to a Seder Monday

Just wrote this

Passover 2024

Tonight as every passover

i will go to a seder

Seder in Hebrew translates to “order”

This year feels different

Contradictions seem to underline every thought we have in these strange unpoetic days

There is no order

Days and nights are

Filled with confusion and grief

This is the night we are to celebrate the exodus of the Hebrew people

From

Egypt where they were

Enslaved beaten and murdered as they built monuments to Pharaohs

Tonight we will sing “ where under every vine and every fig tree we shall live in

peace and unafraid”

This fig tree is a tree whose roots know no ownership but can share its plump fruit with both Arab and Jew and there can be enough for both

Each craving the sweetness of a tender touch and the warmth of the beginning of a simple spring morning

But as through the centuries

There is famine and pestilence in the land and the plagues we read about from the Hagadah say “it would have been enough” still exist

We repeat Dayenu but the plagues only multiply and do not not diminish

Trauma is in the blood of the many and there is no respite

To the destruction that

Modern day Pharaohs have brought upon thousands of innocents

Showering bombs without cessation

Children maimed

Searching for mothers Buried breathless under rubble never to love again

Parents waiting for hostages to be released after a siege that took away the belief that finally a homeland was safe

No one is safe

The blood of many veins tainted with trauma that will not heal

Tonight i will sit with people

As fractured as i feel

We will read from the Haggadah and instead of the Joy of a holiday that celebrates rebirth

There will be profound grief for the loss of order

No seder possible

My throat will be dry and catch there will be

Just Weeping

For the sorrow of the pain that my people are inflicting on those who are hungry homeless hurting

Have no solace that is possible to soothe the agony that hate has wrought on the other.

The only solution is peace

That is why the heart must keep on pumping

Until people understand

They must each taste the succulence of the sweetness of the fig together

Only then can we sing “that we will live in Peace and Unafraid”

Barbara Buloff

4/22/24

Expand full comment
Apr 24Liked by Elise Labott

A terrific column. It perfectly reflects the conflicting feelings a lot of us are dealing with in macro and micro terms. It's hard to believe the utter stupidity on the part of the protesting college students. I feel sorry for the lives of the Jewish and non- Jewish kids and professors whose college experience is forever tainted by the hate being directed at them, and the resulting fear and danger they face instead of the joy of intellectual and personal growth. Where is a Moses when we need one?

Expand full comment